Court Documents

Envirolab carried out testing for toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) on samples of different materials still present on board the ex HMAS Adelaide on March 27 2010. 61 samples were collected and  48 samples tested positive to containing greater than 1mg/kg of PCBs, however 28 samples returned a result of 10 mg/kg or higher. Download the Envirolab reports here. 

Evidence From Werner Hoyt - 15 April 2010 [PDF]

Evidence from Steve Paulsen - 13 April 2010 [PDF]

Evidence from Jim Puckett - 26 June 2010 [PDF]

Lead Paint Test Results - 13 July 2010 [PDF]

PCB Test Results - Envirolab [PDF]

PCB Test Results - NMI [PDF]

Recycling Quote - 3 July 2010

Decision and Reasons for Decision - 15 September 2010

Decision and Reasons for Decision - 15 October 2010 

Thanks to community support and the No Ship Action Group working around the clock for over a year the following items were removed from ex-HMAS Adelaide prior to scuttling:

  • 23 000 square metres of fibreglass insulation
  • 23 000 square metres of painted canvas covering (pictured above)
  • All polyurethane insulation foam from coolrooms
  • Over two tonnes of electrical cable
  • Over 200 junction boxes
  • All ‘exfoliating’ lead paint. 

Recent update to official HMAS Adelaide website: 

The additional works to comply with the Tribunal orders were completed in March 2011. On a precautionary basis, all junction boxes and remnant wiring in electrical boxes, switches, power outlets and similar equipment were removed.

Over 44 tonnes of insulation was removed, which took 25 truckloads to take away for safe disposal.

Where there was paint behind the insulation, it was generally in good condition and only very minor amounts of exfoliated or exfoliating paint needed to be removed.

http://www.hmasadelaide.com/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/150187/Environment_Factsheet.pdf

Many insulation items tested positive for highly toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and the State Govt witness stated in court that insulation would be released into the ocean within five to six years.

Cool room insulation was only removed in the last weeks before scuttling because NSAG threatened to take the matter back to court if they refused to remove 'all insulation’ as ordered by the Tribunal.

The ship contained over 200 junction boxes but as of March this year they had only removed 3. Again due to NSAG pressure the State have now indicated they removed the remaining junction boxes as the Judge ordered.

Despite these wins the ship was still sunk with over twenty tonnes of paint including four tonnes of anti fouling paint and 9 tonnes of lead based paint containing up to 2.3 tonnes of lead (lead content averages 28%)

The paint was never tested for PCBs even though the Federal Government advised it should be and PCBs were commonly added to the paint at the time of Adelaide’s construction to improve adherance and elasticity.

A large amount of plastics in fittings and furniture also remained on the vessel that is destined to become marine debris, endangering marine life and birds.

Why did a small community group have to work so hard to protect our environment from our own government?

Why was marine scientist Professor Bill Gladstone and John Asquith from the Central Coast Community Environment Network and Marine Discovery Centre happy to see the ship dumped last year with all of these toxic items still onboard? 
Listen here to John Asquith and Prof Bill Gladstone's March 2010 interview with Scott Levi on local ABC radio

On Wednesday April 13 all levels of government sold out Avoca Beach by dumping a 4000 tonne warship covered in lead paint in the bay.
Despite repeated requests from the community they refused to test the paint for highly toxic polychlorinated...

On Wednesday April 13 all levels of government sold out Avoca Beach by dumping a 4000 tonne warship covered in lead paint in the bay.

Despite repeated requests from the community they refused to test the paint for highly toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) despite them being present in the paint of the Adelaide’s sister ship.

Chris Hartcher and Barry O'Farrell put a price on the peace of mind and health of the local community, beach and marine environment.
Shame Shame Shame!

Remaining Concerns about plan to dump a warship at Avoca Beach

Court Documents

Shortly before the ex-HMAS Adelaide was found to contain 23 thousand square metres of (average) 28% lead containing paint, and before proper tests for PCBs found them in cables, insulation and other items, Lands Minister Tony Kelly went on national...

Shortly before the ex-HMAS Adelaide was found to contain 23 thousand square metres of (average) 28% lead containing paint, and before proper tests for PCBs found them in cables, insulation and other items, Lands Minister Tony Kelly went on national television to spruike a fantastic story about the ‘environmental ship’ ex-HMAS Adelaide. It then became obvious no problems were found because nobody was looking.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SprSOkNvAc&feature=watch_response

View entire ABC Stateline’s “Scuttled” here.

In 2006 exHMAS Adelaide’s sister ship the USS Oliver Hazard Perry was dismantled and PCBs were found in the paint. 
State Government are refusing to test HMAS Adelaide’s paint for PCBs.  

PCB’s were added to improve the covering ability and elasticity of lead-based paint to prevent cracking.  

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has only ordered 'exfoliating'or 'exfoliated’ lead paint to be removed yet most of the paint is currenlty intact so will remain on the vessel. 

The Tribunals decision states "As there is limited understanding of the specific impacts of lead on the marine environment, especially over the long term and in marine sediments, additonal monitoring is appropriate.“

HMAS ADELAIDE’S PAINT HAS NEVER BEEN TESTED FOR PCBs.
The State govt assured us the ship contained no PCBs and no lead paint- they were wrong.
What else are they wrong about?
HMAS Adelaide’s sister ship was the ex-U.S.S. Oliver Hazard Perry which was...

HMAS ADELAIDE’S PAINT HAS NEVER BEEN TESTED FOR PCBs.

The State govt assured us the ship contained no PCBs and no lead paint- they were wrong.
What else are they wrong about?

HMAS Adelaide’s sister ship was the ex-U.S.S. Oliver Hazard Perry which was dismantled in the U.S. in 2006. PCBs were found in the original electrical cabling as well as in the original base paint primer. PCBs are globally banned due to their highly toxic carcinogenic nature. (#28 of Pucketts affadavit)
http://mercuryrising.com.au/noship/aat/puckett_DOC280610.pdf

’Most consultants that are involved with military or federal cleanup sites know to automatically ask for PCB analysis along with their Pb (Lead) testing.’
http://www.emsltesting.com/pcb_s_in_lead_based_paint_.html

Please vote now on GetUp - No Ship at Avoca!

Please help in this 11th hour - Click this link to vote and add a comment too.
http://suggest.getup.org.au/forums/60819-campaign-ideas/suggestions/1514719-no-ship-at-avoca-?ref=title

The NoShip Action Group has gained momentum in their fight to stop the scuttling of the frigate ex-HMAS Adelaide at Avoca.

The State government are now planning on dumping it April 13.

The vessel will still contain:
23 000 sq metres of lead paint
1 tonne of plastics
2000 tonnes of recyclable steel
200 tonnes of marine grade aluminium

The effects of placing it so close to shore have not been adequately addressed in terms of beach erosion, wave impact and migration of whales.  

Vote now, it is just not worth the risk.

Former Chief Medical Officer for Australia writes to Chris Hartcher - Stop the sinking of the Adelaide

Mr Chris Hartcher
Member for Terrigal
PO Box 3618
Erina NSW 2250

Dear Mr Hartcher

I want to add my name to the number of people who are very concerned that the sinking of the “Adelaide” might still go ahead off Avoca Beach.

As a resident of Avoca Beach but also as a past Chief Health Officer for NSW and former Chief Medical Officer for Australia and a professional expert in public health I am worried about potential health threats posed by dumping toxic materials in the sea no matter how concentrated or diluted they may be. The precautionary principle must always prevail in such cases.

Basically too it is just plain dumb to throw expensive metal garbage into the sea simply for recreational purposes. It is environmental vandalism at the very least.

I trust you will do all in your power to make sure this does not happen.

Yours Sincerely

Dr Tony Adams
Avoca Beach
January 25 2011  

Stateline ABC TV 12/03/10

Watch the story about the scuttling of HMAS Adelaide and how the local community have not been adequately informed and do NOT want this ship. 
ABCTV Stateline Friday 12/3/10 7:30pm

http://www.abc.net.au/news/video/2010/03/12/2844703.htm