Oh buoy were we warned: ship debris on beach
June 3 2011
 SHARP metal sheeting from the ex-HMAS Adelaide washed up along North Avoca Beach on the eve of World Environment Day.
 
Severe storms in the past week littered the beach with ship debris and broke loose two navigational buoys.

The potentially dangerous debris, with some metal sheets up to 2 metres long, marks the beginning of the predicted break-up of the ex-HMAS Adelaide.

The No Ship Action Group has kept a piece of the debris to make a sculpture.

Many supporters of the scuttling claimed the wreck would be positive for the environment and that this was an environmentally friendly sea dumping.

The sculpture will highlight the irony of dumping an ex-naval vessel into the ocean as an ‘artificial reef’ which now endangers swimmers and marine life.

No Ship Action Group warned the frigate was the wrong type of ship to sink, and that it would break up as has its identical sister ship the ex-HMAS Canberra, sunk off the Victorian coast near Geelong in October, 2009.
 
The Geelong ship has cracked and is already breaking up with Parks Victoria issuing a warning to divers on its website 16 months after the ship sunk.
 
It is less two months since the ex-HMAS Adelaide was sunk on April 13 2011 and it is already breaking up.
 
Divers have reported that the hull has cracked. The crack has appeared in the ship’s ‘weak spot’ as outlined by a marine engineer in a  $4000 report NSAG commission in the month before the ex-HMAS was sunk in a last-minute bid to prove to authorities the ship would break up and pollute the bay. Read the report online here. http://bit.ly/fwNZFi
 
The report was the basis of a summons in the Land and Environment Court the day before the scuttling in what was a last-minute bid to stop the dumping. Read the Summons here http://bit.ly/kJi8EB
 
However, Premier Barry O’Farrell chose to ignore the report, as did Member for Terrigal Chris Hartcher.
 
The potentially dangerous metal sections of the ex-HMAS Adelaide made their way to the beach starting on Thursday.
 
One piece of aluminium sheet measuring two metres by 60cm was found in the surf zone on Thursday afternoon.

About 80 smaller sections measuring on average about 20cm by 20cm were seen strewn along the beach.

The sheet is of sandwich construction with air trapped in a honeycomb of very thin aluminium between two sheets of aluminium. The trapped air gives the sheets enough buoyancy to keep them floating
 
According to expert marine engineer, Werner Hoyt, “The material washing ashore are internal partitioning aluminum wall materials not removed during preparation for reefing.”

In this form with razor sharp edges it could prove deadly in the surf zone. A surfer or child struck by a thin sharp sheet this size could sustain a very serious injury.
 
Local surfers want answers. How many of the deadly sheets are still lurking in the surf area from Avoca Beach to North Avoca? This could be a serious hazard to marine life if ingested such as whales, dolphins, turtles and other marine creatures.

“It appears that the Adelaide is becoming the poster child of why ships should no longer be reefed,” Mr Hoyt said. “Cost of reefing is now at four times the raw cost to recycle with out counting the resource recovery. The planners failed to account for differences in construction technologies and their likely behavior when subjected to a reefing environment.”  
 
Once again, two ex-HMAS Adelaide marker buoys broke loose in recent storms This is the second occasion buoys have broken free, this time amidst sea twisters and massive swells.
 
The ship wreck is just 6 metres below the surface and a serious navigational hazard right now as there are no navigational marker buoys there.
 
Rumour has it that one buoy washed up at Wamberal and a reward for $600 is being offered to trawler captains if they find one.
 
The buoy system comprises two navigational marker buoys ($16,000 each) and six mooring buoys.

Debris believed to be from Adelaide dive site washes up at Avoca

Express Advocate 3 June 2011

First paying customers to dive on HMAS Adelaide wreck

Central Coast Express Advocate
May 5, 2011

The debate still rages in the Comments section.

Cracks in the hull, poor visibility, massive swell, misssing buoys, debris on the beach, inflated prices and confusion over permits and mooring site allocation.

Sounds like HMAS Lemonade is off to a predictable start to its short life as a diver’s new toy. 

http://express-advocate-gosford.whereilive.com.au/news/story/first-paying-customers-to-dive-on-hmas-adelaide-wreck/

Channel 10 News 13 April 2011

Channel 7 News 13 April 2011

We Sunk a Boat - youtube clip + song about scuttling the Adelaide that sums up the mentality behind this dive site

Big Men Productions Film re the Lead Paint Protest on Terrigal Beach 2 April 2011

Thanks to community support and the No Ship Action Group working around the clock for over a year the following items were removed from ex-HMAS Adelaide prior to scuttling:

  • 23 000 square metres of fibreglass insulation
  • 23 000 square metres of painted canvas covering (pictured above)
  • All polyurethane insulation foam from coolrooms
  • Over two tonnes of electrical cable
  • Over 200 junction boxes
  • All ‘exfoliating’ lead paint. 

Recent update to official HMAS Adelaide website: 

The additional works to comply with the Tribunal orders were completed in March 2011. On a precautionary basis, all junction boxes and remnant wiring in electrical boxes, switches, power outlets and similar equipment were removed.

Over 44 tonnes of insulation was removed, which took 25 truckloads to take away for safe disposal.

Where there was paint behind the insulation, it was generally in good condition and only very minor amounts of exfoliated or exfoliating paint needed to be removed.

http://www.hmasadelaide.com/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/150187/Environment_Factsheet.pdf

Many insulation items tested positive for highly toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and the State Govt witness stated in court that insulation would be released into the ocean within five to six years.

Cool room insulation was only removed in the last weeks before scuttling because NSAG threatened to take the matter back to court if they refused to remove ‘all insulation’ as ordered by the Tribunal.

The ship contained over 200 junction boxes but as of March this year they had only removed 3. Again due to NSAG pressure the State have now indicated they removed the remaining junction boxes as the Judge ordered.

Despite these wins the ship was still sunk with over twenty tonnes of paint including four tonnes of anti fouling paint and 9 tonnes of lead based paint containing up to 2.3 tonnes of lead (lead content averages 28%)

The paint was never tested for PCBs even though the Federal Government advised it should be and PCBs were commonly added to the paint at the time of Adelaide’s construction to improve adherance and elasticity.

A large amount of plastics in fittings and furniture also remained on the vessel that is destined to become marine debris, endangering marine life and birds.

Why did a small community group have to work so hard to protect our environment from our own government?

Why was marine scientist Professor Bill Gladstone and John Asquith from the Central Coast Community Environment Network and Marine Discovery Centre happy to see the ship dumped last year with all of these toxic items still onboard? 
Listen here to John Asquith and Prof Bill Gladstone’s March 2010 interview with Scott Levi on local ABC radio

On Wednesday April 13 all levels of government sold out Avoca Beach by dumping a 4000 tonne warship covered in lead paint in the bay.
Despite repeated requests from the community they refused to test the paint for highly toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) despite them being present in the paint of the Adelaide’s sister ship.
Chris Hartcher and Barry O’Farrell put a price on the peace of mind and health of the local community, beach and marine environment. Shame Shame Shame!

On Wednesday April 13 all levels of government sold out Avoca Beach by dumping a 4000 tonne warship covered in lead paint in the bay.

Despite repeated requests from the community they refused to test the paint for highly toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) despite them being present in the paint of the Adelaide’s sister ship.

Chris Hartcher and Barry O’Farrell put a price on the peace of mind and health of the local community, beach and marine environment.
Shame Shame Shame!

Scuttling Day Media

A round up of some of the scuttling day media

HMAS Adelaide goes under after dolphin display delays scuttling
Sydney Morning Herald - 13 April 2011

Channel 7 News - 13 April 2011

MSNBC Video - USA turns to recycling warships

SkyNEWs

Protesters to turn backs on ship sinking - Interview Quentin Riley
NineMSN
“The beach is part of me, it’s part of my life and they’re trying to destroy it, and all for money,” Mr Riley told AAP.

Twitter #HMASAdelaide and #LOLphins

We Sunk a Boat - youtube

Dolphins on AAP Video - interview Michelle Meares, Ross Markey

Dolphins scuttle ship scuttling
ABC PM Mark Colvin Interview Ben Smith

ABC Breakfast Fran Kelly Interview MIchelle Meares

Photos Sunrise and The Morning Show

Controversial warship heads for seabed home  ABC TV NEWS - April 11 

Channel 9 News - April 11 - Interview Quentin Riley

Channel 10 Ten News - April 11

SkyNews - April 12

Telegraph UK

See below for link of two pix from Avoca - numbers 13 and 14. Good to see the other side of the world can see the bigger picture.  Pictures of the day: 13 April 2011

Picture 1

Picture 2 -SHAME

Calgary Herald, Canada - Sea to Sky Protest

The day Chris Hartcher dumped on Avoca

The Habitat Advocate
13-4-2011
(click title to read article)

Shipwrecked on the Central Coast

Amidst the activity, a group of protesters emerged from the open marquee on the southern end of the beach, where they had spent the night huddled beneath blankets and sleeping bags, and stared out to sea. Two kilometres offshore - and at the centre of the bitter debate that has polarised the local community over the past 12 months - the imposing hulk of the ex-HMAS Adelaide sat silhouetted against a burnt orange sky awaiting its fate.

Read more: http://www.coastalwatch.com/news/article.aspx?articleId=8797&cateId=36&display=0&title=Shipwrecked%20on%20the%20Central%20Coast#ixzz1JYG3Uqaj

Read here and leave your comments.
Coastalwatch Feature - 15 April 2011

The sun has set on sea dumpingThe tide has turned to recycling
(click image to view larger - NB this image was created by a friend of NSAG last year in Photoshop. We didn’t use it in the campaign partly as we thought the ship looked unrealistically too close and we did not want to give false representation of the sinking - sadly  on the day this is almost exactly what it looked like with the surfers right there. See other media photos showing close proximity to the beach here
Our government spent in excess of $8.3 million on this extreme act of environmental vandalism and reckless waste of precious resources.
They also spent $1 million fighting a small community group that exposed the ship did not comply with cleanup guidelines at the time they wanted to dump it in March 2010. 
The No Ship Action Group also exposed for the first time in Australia the misinformation and false economy of sea dumping ex military vessels at sea.
They have the beautiful and pristine waters of Jervis Bay as their next target. Avoca Beach could not be saved in time but hopefully this can be stopped before it is too late.
Jobs and Dollars Overboard - the economic case against dumping U.S. naval vessels at sea. Report by the Basel Action Network Dec 2010.

The sun has set on sea dumping
The tide has turned to recycling

(click image to view larger - NB this image was created by a friend of NSAG last year in Photoshop. We didn’t use it in the campaign partly as we thought the ship looked unrealistically too close and we did not want to give false representation of the sinking - sadly  on the day this is almost exactly what it looked like with the surfers right there. See other media photos showing close proximity to the beach here

Our government spent in excess of $8.3 million on this extreme act of environmental vandalism and reckless waste of precious resources.

They also spent $1 million fighting a small community group that exposed the ship did not comply with cleanup guidelines at the time they wanted to dump it in March 2010. 

The No Ship Action Group also exposed for the first time in Australia the misinformation and false economy of sea dumping ex military vessels at sea.

They have the beautiful and pristine waters of Jervis Bay as their next target. Avoca Beach could not be saved in time but hopefully this can be stopped before it is too late.

Jobs and Dollars Overboard - the economic case against dumping U.S. naval vessels at sea. Report by the Basel Action Network Dec 2010.

Mother Nature spoke loud and clear
Shame our government didn’t listen

ABC Radio PM Report